Events the lightning conference

‘Scam’ or Iteration — in Berlin, Bitcoin Diehards Still Believe in Lightning


“There’s really this class of trolls on Twitter that likes to troll me, and so they like to say this factor about ‘18 months,’ the place supposedly Lightning was alleged to be prepared in 18 months,” Elizabeth Stark jokingly defined. “At one level I’ll have commented {that a} beta was gonna be out … and we really did ship, by the best way.”

Closing the primary day of shows, the Lightning Labs CEO shared her ideas on the primary stage with enterprise capitalist Jim Patterson. Seated in entrance of a big black banner studying “The Lightning Conference,” one of many pioneers of Bitcoin’s protocol layer for quick and low-cost transactions addressed a number of the considerations that critics wish to tout on social media and web boards. The Lightning Network isn’t being developed quick sufficient, the naysayers declare. Or maybe it’s going to by no means achieve assuaging Bitcoin’s scaling challenges in any respect.

“Here, my philosophy is, nicely, we’re actually to start with of this marathon,” Stark informed an attentive viewers within the central convention space. “We know in regards to the challenges, and if something, I believe they’re thrilling issues to resolve.”

Jeff Gallas and Elizabeth Stark (Photo credit score: Anastasya Stolyarov)

Hackday History

It was February 2015 when Thaddeus (Tadge) Dryja and Joseph Poon revealed their white paper, “The Bitcoin Lightning Network: Scalable Off-Chain Instant Payments.” Seemingly out of nothing (and topping the authors’ personal expectations), the proposal turned a cornerstone in Bitcoin’s first large scaling conflict. Proponents noticed it as one of many key options to allow extra transactions with out compromising Bitcoin’s decentralization and safety. Opponents, in distinction, didn’t imagine it will be prepared in time — if ever.

Within a yr of the white paper’s publication, three totally different — although small — growth groups had began implementing the software program to understand the scaling layer: Blockstream (spearheading the c-lightning implementation), Lightning Labs (spearheading lnd) and ACINQ (spearheading eclair). 

But, as some predictions of Lightning’s timeframe proved too optimistic, skeptics took it as proof that they’d been proper all alongside. “Vaporware,” some commented. Or, even when working software program ought to change into obtainable, the community would certainly evolve right into a hub-and-spoke mannequin, which the fats cats of Blockstream (so some critics would warn) may leverage to become profitable off of relay charges.

It didn’t deter the builders. While often working from throughout the globe, builders often began gathering in particular person as nicely. The 2016 Scaling Bitcoin convention in Milan, for instance, gave a chance to carry the primary “Lightning Summit,” the place a few dozen contributors mentioned protocol requirements. The second summit adopted final yr in Australia. And, since early 2018, the Fulmo crew has been organizing a number of Lightning Hackdays — most of which have been in Berlin, most likely the unofficial world capital of the hacker scene.

Lightning Challenges

Now, the time had come to scale the hackday format up. A mixed effort between volunteers from Fulmo, Lightning Labs and the broader Lightning neighborhood organized the first-ever Lightning Conference in an outdated military bakery constructing within the coronary heart of Berlin.

Sticking to its hackday roots, the higher occasion flooring — reachable via a gated staircase — featured large, darkish picket tables scattered with laptops, cables and Club Mate (a preferred vitality drink in Berliner hacker tradition). Developers joined and left the tables all through the weekend, studying to tinker with the Layer 2 know-how from friends. Across the identical corridor, a row of desks stationed alongside the wall hosted an extravagant assortment of Lightning-enabled toys, merchandising machines and different techy contraptions.

Hackers working diligently on the second-floor hacking desk (photograph credit score: Enid Valu @warmdefeat)

Between the primary convention space and a secondary corridor, two phases supplied platforms to Lightning builders and lovers who’ve come from everywhere in the world to current and talk about their imaginative and prescient, their software program implementations and Lightning functions (“LApps”) for this rising know-how. Counting round 500 attendees, all areas have been nicely attended at virtually any level within the weekend.

Yet, regardless of plenty of buzzing enthusiasm, the main target of lots of the talks wasn’t on how nice the Lightning Network is. The focus is on what isn’t nice in regards to the Lightning Network — but. The presenters spoke about what must be improved. Path discovering (so funds can attain their vacation spot) continues to be a problem. Channel liquidity continues to be a problem as nicely, as are channel administration (together with safety challenges and dependable backups) and — extra usually — person expertise.

The ‘Scam’ Label

The challenges forward are gladly embraced by a few of Lightning’s critics, who sometimes favor different approaches to scaling. Many of them have shifted their vitality and help to altcoins by now: Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin SV or different cryptocurrencies with a main give attention to low-cost and quick transactions. Some will even go as far as to bluntly name the Lightning Network a rip-off.

Outside the brownish-bricked constructing, in what’s finest described because the convention courtyard, the afternoon solar offered an uncharacteristically comfy temperature for Berlin in late October. Enjoying some recent air, Israeli Bitcoin builders Udi Wertheimer and Nadav Ivgi — well-known within the Bitcoin growth neighborhood — chuckled on the suggestion that the Lightning Network may find yourself being a rip-off.

“Who is even alleged to have been scammed?” Wertheimer questioned out loud. “The Lightning Network isn’t funded by some type of opportunistic token sale. It’s simply open-source builders engaged on tasks to make it work.”

Indeed, the Lightning Network didn’t interact in any sort of ICO — nor, as a public community that makes use of bitcoin, may it actually have. Of course, a number of the growth groups engaged on the software program implementations did increase hundreds of thousands of {dollars} from traders; in early October 2019, for instance, ACINQ introduced a funding spherical of $Eight million. And fact be informed, neither the Lightning Network nor the businesses constructing it are assured to succeed.

“But that’s cash from enterprise capitalists — not from common Bitcoin customers,” Ivgi added. “Making dangerous investments is what VCs do. If it doesn’t work out for them, that’s a part of the job.”


The after-party on the night of Saturday, October 19, 2019 — an integral a part of many conferences — happened within the lounge and backyard of a resort close to the bridge connecting the Kreuzberg and Friedrichshain neighborhoods. It’s a brief stroll for individuals who’d later need to attempt their luck stepping into one among Berlin’s iconic nightclubs. (Berliner doormen are famend for refusing entry to anybody who seems unready for an extended night time of techno music.)

The night was about midway via as Rusty Russell joined the after-party, having made it to the convention all the best way from Adelaide, Australia. Russell was the primary particular person on the planet to begin engaged on the Lightning Network in an official capability. Having written a collection of weblog posts making an attempt to translate the Lightning white paper into one thing extra digestible, the Linux veteran started working for Blockstream in mid-2015 to make the know-how actual.

“The fast development of this neighborhood doesn’t shock me, I’ve seen this earlier than,” he mentioned with a seasoned sense of pleasure. By the time Russell first discovered in regards to the Lightning Network, he’d already gathered many years of free and open-source growth expertise: “This occasion jogs my memory of the early Linux days.”

In his speak on Saturday morning, Russell issued a phrase of warning about overselling the promise of Lightning, nonetheless. Where early Bitcoin proponents have been a bit too optimistic about spreading the phrase of Bitcoin as an answer that will supply low-cost funds without end, he expects Lightning Network charges to extend over time as nicely.

Rusty Russell (photograph credit score: Enid Valu @warmdefeat)

Yet, he’s absolutely optimistic in regards to the future.

“I don’t assume the Lightning Network faces any unsolvable issues,” he mentioned. “Conceptually, all of it works out. What it wants now’s laborious work. And that tough work will get simpler as we proceed to maneuver ahead.”

Undeniably, progress is being made. Lightning Labs has simply launched lnd model 0.8.0, bettering on safety, routing and extra. ACINQ is on the point of launch its Phoenix pockets, which is able to make the person expertise slicker than ever (customers gained’t even want to change between on-chain and off-chain funds, because the person interface abstracts this away). The upcoming launch of the favored Electrum bitcoin pockets will include Lightning integration. Innovative proposals like Hyperloop may even profit Bitcoin’s on-chain scaling challenges. The record goes on.

Blockstream engineer Lisa Neigut on enriching Lightning liquidity (photograph credit score: Enid Valu @warmdefeat)

Lightning in The Room

But maybe the most effective proof of how far Lightning has come alongside was showcased at Room 77, the legendary cypherpunk-themed bar and maybe the globally-recognized clubhouse of the Bitcoin neighborhood. As “The Room” is stuffed with dwell jazz music, cigarette smoke and excited chatter, a well-recognized ritual repeated because the convention crowd celebrated a profitable weekend by ordering a spherical of beers: The bearded bartender pulled out a small machine from behind him, not a lot larger than a pack of cigarettes, pressed a button or two, and a QR-code popped up on the small connected display. One cell phone scan and a few seconds later, the transaction confirmed and drinks have been paid for.

Yes, the know-how is younger, and far enchancment nonetheless must occur. Just in current months, a vital bug was discovered (and glued) throughout implementations; a stark reminder that the know-how continues to be considerably experimental, and understanding all its kinks and challenges will most likely be a marathon certainly.

But all through that Sunday night time, in Room 77, Lightning labored.

Thanks to Martin Köppelmann for uplifting the headline.

The put up ‘Scam’ or Iteration — in Berlin, Bitcoin Diehards Still Believe in Lightning appeared first on Bitcoin Magazine.

Source link


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

You may also like

Bitcoin cryptocurrency exchange derivatives financial derivatives okex Tradings

Cryptocurrency Exchange OKEx to Launch Options Trading This Month


Malta-based cryptocurrency change OKEx introduced that it’ll launch crypto choices buying and selling on Dec. 27.

In a press launch on Dec. 9, the change stated that the addition of choices makes OKEx the “first crypto change to supply C2C, spot, futures, perpetual swap, and choices buying and selling underneath the identical roof.” 

The choices will enable the platform’s customers to purchase or promote an underlying asset after paying a premium. While actual choices buying and selling will start on Dec. 27, simulated buying and selling is scheduled to start out in simply three days, on Dec. 12.

A significant improve for OKEx

To implement choices, the agency reportedly upgraded its complete system and infrastructure, together with the addition of an anti-price manipulation system.

The possibility worth is set in real-time by using the Black-Scholes pricing mannequin, which considers volatility, possibility sort, underlying asset worth, time, strike worth…

View More Article
Crypto Ethereum News

Ethereum Developers Are Creating a Revolutionary Open Financial System: Report



To fight failing fiscal insurance policies, foreign money manipulation and a shadow banking system that continues to feed fee-grabbing monetary intermediaries, Ethereum builders are constructing instruments that reimagine how cash flows and the way monetary providers are offered.

In a brand new weblog publish entitled, “2019 Was The Year of DeFi (and Why 2020 Will be Too),” Mason Nystrom, content material marketer on the Ethereum incubator ConsenSys, explains the principle targets of decentralized finance and the Ethereum builders who launched new and authentic options that made DeFi the most well liked motion in crypto in 2019.

Writes Nystrom,

“The present monetary system is comprised of walled gardens with restricted transferability or two-way entry. Where interoperability is feasible, it’s managed by middlemen and rent-seekers. Open finance is outlined by platforms that may work along with a level of transparency with capabilities that complement each other.”

Ethereum is enabling interoperability, programmability and…

View More Article
Bitcoin Cryptocurrencies Denmark money laundering

No More Bitcoin for Nordea Bank Employees, Experts Question the Motive


An act of paternalism or a case of generic Bitcoin (BTC) mistrust? It is tough to make out the precise causes for Nordea Bank’s ban on its 31,500 staff buying and selling in Bitcoin or different cryptocurrencies — even on their very own time — a prohibition that was upheld on Dec. 2 by a Danish courtroom.

In a press launch posted by the courtroom following its ruling, Nordea Bank famous that, “Employees are permitted to maintain any current [crypto] holdings,” although it added that they had been inspired to promote them.

As reported by Cointelegraph, Denmark’s finance trade union, Finansforbundet, introduced a class-action lawsuit in opposition to Nordea’s cryptocurrency prohibition in 2018 on the grounds that the ban interfered with staff’ private lives. It seems that the financial institution, the biggest monetary group within the Nordic international locations (Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway…

View More Article
Bitcoin Bitcoin price Market analysis

Sorry — But Bitcoin Can Still Drop to $2.7K While Everyone’s Bullish


As the Bitcoin worth (BTC) begins to slowly ascend, the query on everybody’s minds is whether or not the most recent backside is in, or whether or not there’s extra ache forward.  

In this text, I’ll goal to supply some perception as to what one can count on based mostly on the data from the charts. 

Daily crypto market performance

Daily crypto market efficiency. Source:

Lower CME hole to be stuffed

BITCOIN CME futures daily chart

BITCOIN CME futures day by day chart. Source: TradingView

In final week’s evaluation, I identified that the CME hole was larger than the weekend worth, 7% larger in reality, and as anticipated this hole was stuffed on Dec. four as a $560 candle appeared out of nowhere…

View More Article
Altcoin Blockchain Cryptocurrencies cryptocurrency exchange Ethereum Hard Fork

Ethereum Istanbul Hard Fork Get Support From Major Crypto Exchanges


Following the profitable Ethereum Istanbul laborious fork replace, a number of in style exchanges have introduced their official assist for the community improve.

Yesterday, on Dec. 7, the Ethereum’s community noticed ample collaboration between node operators and miners to replace the software program to assist the Istanbul laborious fork.

Some crypto exchanges even sounded their willingness to replace just a few days previous to the scheduled laborious fork.

A extensively supported laborious fork

Notably, Binance introduced assist for the improve on Dec. 5 and the day afterwards its U.S. subsidiary did the identical. Coinbase additionally tweeted yesterday that Ethereum and ERC20 deposits and withdrawals have been resumed on its buying and selling platforms and the node improve has been accomplished.

The web site devoted to reporting the state of Ethereum assist of crypto change Kraken additionally means that…

View More Article
Bitcoin BTC grayscale Millennials News

Millennials Opting for Bitcoin Investment Over Netflix and Disney, Reports Charles Schwab



Millennials would fairly have publicity to Bitcoin than spend money on Netflix or Disney, in line with the lastest evaluation from Charles Schwab.

A brand new report from the funding large exhibits Millennials are opting to purchase Grayscale’s Bitcoin Trust, which is backed by BTC, as a substitute of shares of Microsoft, Walt Disney, Netflix or Warren Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway.

The report additionally exhibits Millennials specifically are allocating a bigger portion of their funding portfolios to money and exchange-traded-funds (ETFs) in comparison with different buyers.

Mutual funds and Apple shares proceed to make up the most important holding within the accounts of all age teams, Charles Schwab reveals. 

“SDBAs are brokerage accounts inside retirement plans, together with 401(ok) and different varieties of retirement plans, which members can use to spend money on shares, bonds, ETFs, mutual funds and…

View More Article